Compare repair and replacement over the same number of years
Comparing a repair bill with a new appliance's price tag is misleading. Here is the fair way: the same period, every cost you will pay, and room for 'it depends'.

In this guide
Short answer: do not compare a repair bill with a new appliance's price tag. They buy different things: a repair keeps an older machine going, while a new one gives you more years of use. To compare fairly, choose a period (say five years), add up everything you would pay in each case over that period, and look at more than one scenario for how long the repair lasts. This is the fair way to compare repair and replacement.
Key takeaways
- Same period for both choices: this is the single most important rule.
- Count every cost: the repair or full replacement cost, electricity, and a later replacement if the repair does not last.
- Unknown costs stay unknown. Treating them as zero quietly tips the result.
- Run at least two scenarios: the repair lasts, and the repair fails early.
- If the results are close, other things should decide: convenience, features, waste and how much risk you accept.
Why a price tag comparison misleads
Imagine a $250 repair quote and a $900 new washing machine. "The repair is less than a third of the price" sounds convincing. But the comparison leaves out three things:
- Time. The new machine should keep working for years after the repaired one gives up.
- Running costs. An older machine may use more electricity and water.
- Risk. The repaired machine may need another repair, or a replacement, sooner than you hope.
A fair comparison puts all three on the table.
The method in four steps
1. Choose a comparison period
Pick a number of years that matters to you, for example how long you plan to stay in your home, or five years as a default. Both choices are compared over exactly this period.
2. List the costs for "repair first"
- The full repair quote: parts, labour, call-out and tax.
- Electricity (and water, if relevant) for the old machine each year.
- If the repair might not last the whole period: the cost of replacing it later, plus the new machine's running costs for the remaining years.
3. List the costs for "replace now"
- The full replacement cost: price, delivery, installation, parts, removal of the old one and tax. See the full cost of a new appliance.
- Electricity (and water) for the new machine each year.
4. Compare the totals, scenario by scenario
Do it once assuming the repair lasts the whole period, and once assuming it fails early. If both scenarios point the same way, you have a clear answer. If they point different ways, the answer depends on how long the repair lasts, and that is the question to put to the technician.
A worked example (illustrative, not market prices)
These figures are made up to show the arithmetic.
- Repair quote: $250. Full replacement cost: $900.
- Electricity and water: old machine $60 a year, new machine $40 a year.
- Comparison period: 6 years.
| Scenario | Repair first | Replace now | Lower |
|---|---|---|---|
| Repair lasts 6 years | $250 + 6 × $60 = $610 | $900 + 6 × $40 = $1,140 | Repair, by $530 |
| Repair lasts 3 years, then you replace | $250 + 3 × $60 + $900 + 3 × $40 = $1,450 | $1,140 | Replace, by $310 |
The result depends on how long the repair lasts, so the honest conclusion is "it depends". It also tells you what to ask: how confident is the technician, and what warranty backs the repair?
What is left at the end of the period
In the second scenario, the machine you buy in year 3 is only three years old at the end of the period. In the "replace now" case, the machine is six years old. The younger machine is worth more to you. Our calculator can include an estimate of this remaining value as a separate, clearly labelled adjustment, so it never hides inside the cash totals.
When the results are close
If the two totals are within a small margin, the money does not clearly favour either choice. Our calculator calls results "similar" when they are within 5% or a small fixed amount, whichever is larger. In that case, decide on other grounds:
- Convenience: how quickly can each option be done?
- Features or size you need now.
- Waste: repairing keeps a working machine in use.
- Risk: how much would a second breakdown disrupt you?
Common mistakes
- Comparing the repair with the sticker price, without delivery, installation and removal.
- Forgetting running costs, or using a running cost for the new machine but not the old one.
- Treating a cost you have not been told as zero.
- Assuming a repair will last forever, or that it is sure to fail soon.
- Ignoring safety: an appliance that is unsafe should not stay in use, whatever the numbers say.
Do it with your own numbers
The repair-or-replace calculator follows exactly this method. It checks safety first, keeps unknown costs visible, and shows each scenario separately. Pair it with the replacement cost worksheet and the running-cost calculator if you need to work out those inputs first.
Repair and replacement compared: a template you can copy
| Over ___ years | Repair first | Replace now |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront cost (full quote / full replacement cost) | ||
| Running cost per year × years | ||
| Later replacement if the repair fails (scenario 2 only) | — | |
| Unknown lines (list them) | ||
| Total |
Fill it in twice: once with the repair lasting the whole period, once with it failing early. If repair and replacement swap places between the two, ask the technician how long the repair should last.
Frequently asked questions
What comparison period should I choose?
One that matches your plans, such as how long you expect to stay in your home. If unsure, try two periods, for example 3 and 6 years, and see whether the answer changes.
Should I include interest or inflation?
For most household decisions, plain cash totals over the period are enough. If you want to include the time value of money, our calculator shows that as a separate adjusted figure next to the cash totals.
Is repairing always better for the environment?
Keeping a working appliance in use usually avoids the impact of making a new one. A very inefficient old machine can narrow that gap over many years, so running costs are worth checking.
Sources
Check for a recall before you pay for a repair
A recall can mean a free fix or replacement. Search with the model number from the rating plate. “No match” does not prove a machine is safe.


